Skip to main content

Criticism.

 Subject
Subject Source: Art & Architecture Thesaurus
Scope Note: Analyzing and evaluating the quality of man-made objects, literary works and documents, actions or projects. For critical descriptions or analyses of relatively recent works or events, use ""reviews"" .

Found in 70 Collections and/or Records:

Papers concerning East African literature., 1968-1981.

 Sub-Series
Identifier: Acc.9851/38-52
Scope and Contents From the Record Group:

Concerning his doctoral thesis, books and broadcasts, his involvement in East African literature, his editorship of 'Journal of Commonwealth literature' and convenorship of the Scottish Poetry Library.

Includes lectures notes, drafts, histories, correspondence and interviews.

Dates: 1968-1981.

Papers concerning literary matters, chiefly collected by Sir Walter Scott., 1801-1826, undated.

 File
Identifier: MS.891
Scope and Contents The papers include:(i) Notes by David Herd on Scottish poetry, 1801, [?1804], undated (folios 1-18);(ii) Criticisms by David Herd and others of David Irving’s ‘Lives of the Scottish poets’, [?1804] (folios 17-56);(iii) Papers connected with Sir Walter Scott’s inquiries into Alexander Pope, 1821, undated (folios 61-63);(iv) List of works of C R Maturin, perhaps drawn up in connexion with a project that Scott should edit them (folio 64);...
Dates: 1801-1826, undated.

Papers of Alexander Scott.

 Fonds
Identifier: Acc.12236
Scope and Contents

Includes correspondence, noteboooks, and manuscripts and typescripts of poetry, fiction, plays, autiobiographical and critical works.

Dates: 1931-1981.

Papers of Duncan Glen.

 Fonds
Identifier: Acc.11848
Scope and Contents

Papers concern Glen`s poetry, critical works on Hugh MacDiarmid, genealogy of the Glen family and Akros publications, including editorial correspondence.

Dates: 1958-1998.

Papers of G S Fraser.

 Fonds
Identifier: Acc.8002
Scope and Contents

Comprising manuscripts, corrected typescripts, and proofs of poems and critical work, with 86 letters from correspondents, including Ronald Bottrall, Lawrence Durrell, William Empson, and Kathleen Raine.

Dates: 1948-1978.

Papers of Kenneth White.

 Fonds
Identifier: Acc.11211
Scope and Contents

Includes manuscripts, typescripts and proofs of literary and critical works and related correspondence.

Dates: 1978-1995.

Papers of Sir Charles Elliot concerning Demerara and slavery., ?1830-?1833.

 File
Identifier: MS.21219
Scope and Contents The contents are as follows: (i) Rough notes, 1831, on the right of the British Crown to legislate by decree of Privy Council for Demerara (folio 1); (ii) Draft legislation, ?1830-1833, concerning poor relief, employment law, the suppression of vagrancy, and the abolition of domestic slavery (folio 13); (iii) Draft legislation, ?1832-1833, concerning the proposed emancipation of slaves (folio 73); (iv) Memoranda, ?1833, on recent demographic trends among the slave population (folio 95); (v)...
Dates: ?1830-?1833.

Papers, undated, of Hugh Dalrymple Murray Kynynmound concerning classics and literature., Early 18th century.

 File
Identifier: MS.12811
Scope and Contents The contents are as follows. (i) Notes and translations from, and critical essays concerning, the works of Horace (folio 1); (ii) 'Apology for Numa, Horace & Virgil' (folio 71); (iii) 'History of Patrician desertations' (folio 91); (iv) 'The Compendious Orator' (folio 95); (v) 'Dennis Bond from the banks of Phlegethon to the Club on the banks of the Thames' (folio 105); (vi) 'The History of Robin Slip-String the Schoolmaster of Goatham' (folio 116); (vii) 'Rory Dall, a burlesque' (folio...
Dates: Early 18th century.

Research of Duncan Glen, including press cuttings, newspapers and periodicals, relating to Hugh MacDiarmid., 1958-1967, undated.

 Series
Identifier: Acc.10094/39-61
Scope and Contents From the Record Group:

Includes manuscripts and corrected typescripts of poems, articles, reviews and essays, and includes critical work on Hugh MacDiamrid.

Dates: 1958-1967, undated.

Reviews of the works of Ian Rankin., 1983-2014.

 Sub-Series
Identifier: MSS.50571-50580
Scope and Contents

This series contains published reviews of the creative works of Ian Rankin. Included are both press cuttings and complete periodicals containing the reviews. Many of the press cuttings are photocopies sent to Rankin via an agency.

Dates: 1983-2014.

Richard Wharton, "Observations on the Authenticity of Bruce`s Travels" (1800), with extensive annotations by William George Browne.

 Item
Identifier: Acc.8454
Scope and Contents

With a letter, 1789, of James Bruce to George Robinson.

Dates: 1789, 1800.

Student notes of the ‘Lectures on rhetoric and belles lettres’ of Hugh Blair.

 File
Identifier: MS.850
Scope and Contents

The lectures contain (folios 51 verso, 59 verso, 76 verso) the criticisms of Dr Johnson omitted from the published ‘Lectures’, and in particular the rendering of a passage of Addison in the style of Johnson (folio 83) quoted in part by Boswell in his ‘Life’ (edited by Birkbeck Hill, 1934, etc., volume iii, page 172).

Dates: 18th century.

Various editorial papers of Christopher Murray Grieve, 'Hugh MacDiarmid'., 1953, [1962, or before], undated.

 File
Identifier: MS.27081
Scope and Contents

The contents are as follows. (i) Brief pieces written to fill up spaces in magazines, and other short prose writings, 1953, ?1962, undated (folio 1); (ii) Criticisms by Hugh MacDiarmid of work by another writer, undated (folio 77); (iii) Glossaries of Scots words, undated (folio 82); (iv) Introductory note and list of proposed contents for MacDiarmid's ‘Collected poems’ (Edinburgh, 1962) (folio 99). These are followed (folio 112) by suggestions for the contents by M L Rosenthal.

Dates: 1953, [1962, or before], undated.

Work entitled `Buchanan Revis`d [:] Annotations or Animadversions on Buchanan`s Historie and his Dialogue, etc.` consisting of criticisms of George Buchanan’s ‘Return Scoticarum historia’ (folio 7) and his ‘De Jure Regni apud Scotos’ (folio 64) by Sir James Turner, preceded by various items of introductory and explanatory matter.

 Item
Identifier: Adv.MS.31.1.14
Scope and Contents Although the author details the circumstances in which he began, lost, rewrote and revised his criticisms and had them bound, a period ranging from 1643 to 1679, his name nowhere appears; but he has been identified as the soldier and author Sir James Turner.The criticisms are followed (folio 64) by two satirical writings by Turner purporting to be a letter of Don Francesco Gomez de Quevedo Villegas with the impossible date of 1506, and a letter, 1582, of ‘Philander of Sitwald’....
Dates: 1643-1679.